Dear Editor,

I have observed with keen interest the recent announcement of candidates contesting the St. Phillip’s South constituency, which lists four contenders. The anomaly, however, does not lie in the number of candidates but rather in the peculiar inclusion of one who presently serves as an Independent Senator, appointed by His Excellency, the Governor-General.

This development raises serious concerns regarding constitutional propriety, ethical consistency, and the principle of impartiality expected of members of the Upper House. An Independent Senator, by definition, is appointed to serve the national interest – free from partisan allegiance. Their primary function is to deliberate on legislation objectively, offering balance and wisdom uncolored by political ambition or party loyalty.

When such a senator publicly declares candidacy on behalf of a political party, a profound conflict of interest emerges. It undermines both the spirit and purpose of their independent appointment. Continuing to occupy the senatorial seat while simultaneously campaigning under a party banner erodes public confidence in the independence of the Senate and raises legitimate questions about the senator’s ability to perform legislative duties without bias.

The Constitution entrusts the Governor-General with the appointment of Independent Senators precisely because they are meant to remain above the fray of partisan politics. By seeking to contest elections under a party ticket, the senator has, in essence, relinquished that neutrality. To maintain the dignity of the Upper House and uphold public trust in our democratic institutions, it would be both prudent and principled for the senator to resign the independent appointment forthwith.

This is not a matter of personal judgment but one of constitutional ethics and institutional integrity. Our parliamentary system depends on clear boundaries between roles that are political and those that are meant to remain nonpartisan. Blurring that line risks setting a dangerous precedent that could compromise the credibility of the Senate as a nonpartisan reviewing chamber.

I pray that principled action prevails!

Regards,

Watchful and Non-Aligned (Independent) Constituent