A public challenge to ASPIRE by Brent Simon
ASPIRE’s latest contribution raises a fundamental question about the direction in which we want Antigua and Barbuda to move: Why is so much energy being invested in seeking legal accommodation for prostitution and abortion, rather than encouraging greater sexual responsibility, personal discipline and moral accountability among women?
In invoking St. Augustine’s lesser-evil argument, ASPIRE makes the case that prostitution should be regulated rather than prohibited. But there is a fundamental distinction between acknowledging that an activity exists and advocating for its legal accommodation. The fact that something may be difficult to eliminate does not automatically make its normalisation a worthwhile public objective.
Why should our national conversation centre on making prostitution a safer or more acceptable arrangement rather than encouraging women to pursue self-respect, education, economic independence and choices that do not involve the commercialisation of their bodies?
The same question aplies to abortioin. Why is the emphasis so heavily placed on securing greater legal access to terminating pregnancies, while comparatively little attention is given to sexual restraint, responsible decision-making and preventing unwanted pregnancies in the first place?
A society cannot continualy separate personal choices from their consequences and then expect legislation to resolve the resulting problems. Legal permission does not automatically equate to moral legitimacy, just as regulation does not transform every activity into a socially desirable one.
ASPIRE has also advanced arguments involving rape and sexual violence. These are serious matters that deserve serious treatment. However, claims about their prevalence must be supported by credible evidence. Police reports do not capture every incident, and birth statistics alone cannot establish the prevalence of rape. Neither should selective interpretation of statistics be used to manufacture a public argument.
There is also the question of the courts. The recent High Court proceedings have produced a judgment that ASPIRE must address on its merits. Continued disagreement with a judicial decision is legitimate, but the public deserves more than an endless cycle of litigation without a meaningful discussion of the social outcomes being pursued.
If ASPIRE’s mission is the advancement and protection of women, then Antiguans and Barbudans are entitled to ask what vision of womanhood its advocacy seeks to promote.
Our women deserve more than advocacy that concentrates on accommodating the consequences of sexual behaviour. They deserve encouragement to exercise sound judgment, uphold their dignity, make responsible choices and recognise the value of human life.
The question is not simply what the law permits. It is what kind of society we are encouraging ourselves to become.
ASPIRE owes the people of Antigua and Barbuda a clear answer: Why is the fight for legal accommodation receiving so much attention, while the promotion of sexual responsibility, personal accountability and moral standards appears to receive so little?
This article was originally published by Antigua News Room. Read the original article here: LETTER: Why Fight to Normalise What We Should Be Discouraging?.

