We are most grateful for Mr. Brent Simon’s very thoughtful letter (November 19). Any good public policy needs constructive disagreement, so we welcome his reasonable concerns and questions.
Mr. Simon invites us to respond. Here then is our effort:
One:
Gender. We must note that throughout his comments, he consistently places the burden of sexual responsibility, dignity, self-respect and education on women and only women. That exposes an unfortunate gender bias. Women do not get pregnant all by themselves.
Indeed, across the Caribbean, 80% of pregnancies among teenagers result from relations with men 20 years and older. This would make adolescents victims of male irresponsibility and coercion, whether physical, psychological, or economic.
Two:
“Legal permission does not automatically equate to moral legitimacy.” Correct. Gee, this is precisely the distinction we set out to make. Legality and Morality are different domains. Making something legal does not make it moral. Slavery was legal and supported by the church. Conversely, making some criminal does not make it immoral. That tension is the typical basis of many revolutions.
Forced choice eliminates the exercise of conscience and therefore erases any prospect of moral conduct. Moral behaviour requires freedom of choice.
Three:
Direction. “ASPIRE’s latest contribution raises a fundamental question about the direction in which we want Antigua and Barbuda to move.” Again correct. Across the Caribbean, we have had criminal abortion laws for some 150 years and yet we have the highest abortion rate in the world. This should be persuasive evidence that we are stuck in the wrong direction.
We appreciate the difficulty of seeing decriminalisation as a solution; it is counterintuitive. But we do not need to struggle with this abstraction. We can look at the facts. Among countries with low abortion rates (<15 per 1,000 women 15-44 per year) 95% have legal abortion; while countries with high abortion rates (>30) 62% rely on criminal laws.
All the former colonial countries from which we inherited our draconian criminal abortion laws – England, France, Netherlands, Portugal, and Spain – now have legal abortion. Their abortion rates are all low, our are all high, very high.
Mr. Simon might be interested to learn that earlier this year, the UK Parliament expunged the records of all women ever convicted of abortion from the 1800s. This is nothing short of an apology and an admission that their criminal law was unjust, harmful and ineffective.
Four:
Education and Values: No doubt, Mr. Simon will be relived to learn that ASPIRE is conducting a pilot study in Grenada to strengthen Health and Family Life Education (HFLE). We have reached out to religious leaders across the Caribbean. Very few have shown the courage to speak publicly although many are aware of the injustice of our criminal laws.
If we are truly interested in the sanctity of life, the path to fewer abortions lies in eliminating legal barriers. We must decriminalise abortion.
Sincerely,
ASPIRE
This article was originally published by Antigua News Room. Read the original article here: LETTER: Thank you, Mr. Brent Simon – ASPIRE.

