More
    HomeSocietyOPINION: They Say You Own APUA But All You Get Are The...

    OPINION: They Say You Own APUA But All You Get Are The Bills!

    Published on

    spot_img

    The notion that you, the people of Antigua and Barbuda own APUA is generally considered a self-evident fact that no one dares to question nor challenge.

    This fallacy that you own APUA is derived from your assumption that a democratic government means that you, the people, control the things that government controls.

    That seemingly naive assumption is understandable because you have been told that democracy means “government of the people, by the people and for the people”.

    You therefore naturally conclude that if government is the people, then government assets are owned and controlled by the people.

    In your mind, there is no difference between the people and the government, right?

    Hold a minute! Nothing could be farther from the truth!

    Just like democracy is a man-made ideal that seldom works in practice, so too is the notion that the people own and control government assets.

    It has been my experience in Antigua and Barbuda that democracy, in its truest sense, has never been our leaders’ intent.

    I heard former Prime Minister VC Bird declare with my own ears that Antigua and Barbuda is a Social Democracy, a type of socialist state where the factors of production are ultimately controlled by the government and not you, the citizen yourself.

    This has been the path that successive administrations have travelled and continue to travel.

    In a perfect world, we would wish that we lived in a country where our government would bow to our wishes, but in reality, to think that we operate in a democratic country is just a comforting fantasy.

    The truth is, your government is controlled by a group of elites who, more often than not, rule according to their self-interests, which are primarily to seek re-election and line their pockets.

    I have further observed for some time now how government officials have conveniently asserted that APUA is owned by the people of Antigua and Barbuda when it suits their purpose at the time.

    The government uses the “ownership” narrative to manipulate the public into accepting practices which under normal circumstances would be condemned as unjust, unfair or anti-competitive.

    Some of you may argue that the Public Utilities Act Cap 359 establishes a statutory corporation with the legal powers to hold and dispose of property with a board appointed by Cabinet under the direction of the responsible minister, however this arrangement has NEVER resulted in the ordinary Antiguan and Barbudan having a say in APUA’s management, pricing, policies or strategic direction.

    So-called public ownership in APUA does not translate into public accountability and tangible benefits. We must therefore question the ownership.

    Someone who owns any type of property has certain legal rights, namely:

    1. The right to possession;

    2. The right to control;

    3. The right to use and enjoy the benefits;

    4. The right to exclude others;

    5. The right to transfer ownership.

    Tell me, can you walk right into APUA’s Independence Drive office and remove one of the office chairs and take it home without a struggle with the security guard or the possibility of being arrested?

    Can you tell APUA not to cut off your electricity when you are over 30 days in arrears?

    Are you benefiting from the best services available or from the best rates in the local and regional markets?

    How about telling APUA to cut off the electricity of your rude and disrespectful neighbour who always plays loud music that disturbs your peaceful Sunday mornings?

    If APUA is yours, surely you can exclude this miscreant from receiving services!

    How about you selling an APUA asset to fund your new home?

    Can you legally exercise any of the five rights I listed above?

    If you cannot, then you do not own APUA, plain and simple!

    You are technically not even a shareholder with the power to influence decisions with APUA at a shareholders’ meeting.

    The only connection you have with APUA is to pay its usurious bills and cover its debts as a taxpayer.

    Even if four thousand of you presented a petition to the cabinet, you have absolutely no power to influence how APUA is run.

    Who controls APUA, effectively owns APUA.

    And that would be the elites and their cronies who run your government.

    It is these elites who determine who get free electricity, free water, free mobile services and free internet services. They can even block you from receiving any of APUA services if they please.

    They decide who get waivers, who pays for new electricity poles; who gets contracts with APUA.

    They decided which private company is allowed to supply APUA with generated power while feigning righteous indignation against the false horrors of permitting Flow and Digicel to offer highspeed internet services.

    This raises another tightly held fallacy. The fallacy that the interests of the elites who run the government will always align with your interests.

    If you are a reasonable person, take a look at the concessions outlined in the Paradise Found (Project) Act 2015 and let me know what in that act of parliament aligns with your interests, particularly if you are a Barbudan.

    The promotion of the fallacy that you own state assets including APUA is pure manipulation.

    It has been my observation that the government sells us these fallacies for the sole purpose of making us willing to accept and settle for substandard outcomes or unjust, immoral government policies and failures.

    Let us turn on our critical thinking and reject the government’s deliberate manipulation of our sense of right and wrong.

    What goes against your self-interest by allowing Flow and Digicel to offer you highspeed internet at a lower price?

    Even the Internet Society (ISOC) gives Antigua and Barbuda a “Very Poor” rating for Market Competition. See for yourself via the following link:

    https://pulse.internetsociety.org/en/reports/AG

    What these elites are doing to Flow and Digicel is patently immoral and wrong!

    Don’t be fooled by the ownership narrative!

    The next time government tells you that APUA belongs to you, ask yourself one simple question: Does that ownership give me better services, lower prices, greater choice or any meaningful say in how APUA is managed?

    If the answer is no, then perhaps we should stop celebrating the illusion of ownership and start demanding the benefits and accountability that public ownership is supposed to deliver.

    An institution that supposedly belongs to the people should serve the interests of the people—not merely the interests of those who control it

    This article was originally published by Antigua News Room. Read the original article here: OPINION: They Say You Own APUA But All You Get Are The Bills!.

    Latest articles

    Teachers union condemns proposed changes to school hours, calls on education minister to abandon plan

    The Antigua and Barbuda Union of Teachers (A&BUT) has strongly condemned Education Minister Daryll...

    LETTER: The War Against Men: When Equality Becomes Hostility

    Dear Editor,Our society has been degraded to an environment that hates men. Over the...

    LETTER: Thank you, Mr. Brent Simon – ASPIRE

    We are most grateful for Mr. Brent Simon’s very thoughtful letter (November 19). Any...

    Education minister says government will consult teachers’ union on school-hours proposal

    Education Minister Daryl Matthew says the government has not decided to change public secondary...

    More like this

    Teachers union condemns proposed changes to school hours, calls on education minister to abandon plan

    The Antigua and Barbuda Union of Teachers (A&BUT) has strongly condemned Education Minister Daryll...

    LETTER: The War Against Men: When Equality Becomes Hostility

    Dear Editor,Our society has been degraded to an environment that hates men. Over the...

    LETTER: Thank you, Mr. Brent Simon – ASPIRE

    We are most grateful for Mr. Brent Simon’s very thoughtful letter (November 19). Any...