PM Browne rejects Eli Fuller’s apology as insincere but says he forgives him
Prime Minister Gaston Browne has rejected an apology from environmental activist Eli Fuller following their heated confrontation over a beach access petition, accusing Fuller of disrespecting him despite their apparent agreement on the issue.
Browne described Fuller’s apology as insincere and dismissed claims that the public dispute had raised concerns about the safety of Fuller’s family and employees. However, after outlining several longstanding grievances against the activist, the prime minister said he was prepared to forgive him.
The latest exchange followed an open letter in which Fuller apologized for any offense he may have caused Browne and announced that he would temporarily withdraw from social media because of growing hostility surrounding the disagreement.
The dispute began after Fuller presented Browne with a petition signed by more than 4,100 people seeking improved public access to beaches in Antigua and Barbuda, particularly Jolly Harbour’s South Beach.
The petition calls for practical public parking and convenient access to the beach, along with broader measures to protect traditional beach access throughout the country.
Browne previously acknowledged using profanity during his encounter with Fuller, saying he cursed the activist after Fuller told him to burn the petition.
In his open letter, Fuller sought to ease tensions, explaining that he had welcomed the opportunity to meet the prime minister and had initially been encouraged by Browne’s response to the petition.
“I would like to sincerely apologise for anything I may have said or done that you found offensive. That was never my intention,” Fuller wrote.
He maintained that his campaign was motivated by concerns about changes affecting traditional beach access rather than any personal or political dispute with the prime minister.
“I had absolutely no intention of insulting you, offending you, or challenging you to any sort of public confrontation or media duel,” Fuller wrote.
He said he had hoped the meeting would provide an opportunity for meaningful discussions about an issue affecting Antiguans and Barbudans.
Fuller also rejected any suggestion that his advocacy was driven by political ambitions, declaring that he had no interest in entering politics.
“I simply care about this country, its people, and the natural environment that makes it so special,” he wrote.
But Fuller said the increasingly hostile atmosphere surrounding the disagreement had become troubling, particularly because of its potential impact on people close to him.
“The hostility that has developed online has reached a point where I am genuinely concerned about the safety and well-being of my family and even my employees,” he wrote.
He said no public disagreement justified exposing loved ones or employees to potential danger and announced that he would take a break from social media.
Browne, however, responded by questioning the sincerity of the apology and accusing Fuller of misrepresenting what occurred during their meeting.
“There is nothing genuine about this apology,” Browne wrote.
The prime minister said he had welcomed Fuller, accepted the petition, shaken his hand and praised him for his advocacy.
According to Browne, the two were in agreement on the substance of the petition, making Fuller’s subsequent conduct particularly objectionable to him.
“And, when I thought you were delivering the petition, on which we are fully aligned; you chose to disrespect and violate my hospitality,” Browne wrote.
Browne also disputed Fuller’s suggestion that the online hostility had created safety concerns for his relatives and employees.
He accused the activist of having “fabricated another drama that people are trying to hurt him and his family.”
“That’s not the Antiguan culture,” Browne wrote. “We argue vehemently, we cuss and then we make up.”
The prime minister went beyond the immediate disagreement over the petition, raising several allegations about Fuller’s previous criticism of him.
Browne alleged that Fuller had accused him of corruption, suggested he should be imprisoned over the creation of Peace Beach and questioned his ability to own beachfront property as a Black man.
He also accused Fuller of organizing protests outside his beach property.
The allegations were made in Browne’s response and were not addressed individually in Fuller’s open letter.
“You all must allow black leaders in this country to strive, instead of unjustifiably tearing them down,” Browne wrote.
Despite rejecting the apology and criticizing Fuller’s conduct, Browne concluded his response by extending forgiveness.
“I genuinely forgive you for your infractions against me,” the prime minister wrote.
Fuller, meanwhile, indicated that his decision to withdraw temporarily from social media should not be interpreted as an abandonment of the campaign for improved beach access.
He expressed hope that other supporters would continue advocating for the changes outlined in the petition.
“Perhaps it is time for others to carry some of the weight,” Fuller wrote.
“I remain hopeful that the concerns raised by the petition will be given the consideration they deserve, regardless of my personal involvement.”
The exchange leaves the two men publicly at odds over their encounter, even as Browne maintains that he supports the objectives of the petition.
Neither the prime minister’s response nor Fuller’s open letter provided a timetable for specific measures to improve public parking or access at Jolly Harbour’s South Beach.
This article was originally published by Antigua News Room. Read the original article here: PM Browne Calls Fuller’s Apology Insincere, Says He Forgives Him After Beach Access Dispute.

