More
    HomeSocietyLETTER: Aspire, Thank You For Responding. But The Central Question Remains Unanswered.

    LETTER: Aspire, Thank You For Responding. But The Central Question Remains Unanswered.

    Published on

    spot_img

    I welcome ASPIRE’s response to my earlier letter. Public disagreement is healthy, and organisations advocating changes to public policy should expect their positions to be questioned. But responding to a concern and actually answering it are two different things.

    However, having read ASPIRE’s reply, I believe the most important question remains unanswered: What exactly does ASPIRE want Antigua and Barbuda to do about prostitution, and what kind of society does it believe that policy will create?

    That is not a side issue. It goes to the heart of the organisation’s advocacy.

    The question of prostitution

    ASPIRE previously invoked St Augustine’s argument of the lesser evil in support of regulating prostitution. That position deserves more than a passing reference. What does regulation mean in practical terms?

    Is ASPIRE advocating the removal of criminal penalties for people selling sexual services? Is it proposing licensed brothels, a regulated commercial sex industry, or some other arrangement? What safeguards would be put in place to address exploitation, trafficking, coercion and economic vulnerability? And what evidence demonstrates that the proposed model would produce better outcomes in Antigua and Barbuda?

    There is an important distinction between protecting people who are vulnerable to exploitation and creating a formal framework for the commercial exchange of sexual services. Those are not automatically the same policy objective.

    Calling something the lesser evil does not answer whether it should be encouraged, accommodated or institutionalised. Nor does it establish that regulation will solve the problems associated with the activity.

    Antiguans deserve a clear explanation of the policy being proposed, not just the moral philosophy being used to defend it.

    Statistics need context, not convenient interpretation

    ASPIRE accuses me of gender bias because I spoke about sexual responsibility, dignity and self-respect among women. In support of its argument, it cites a figure stating that 80 per cent of teenage pregnancies involve men aged 20 and older.

    Let us examine that figure properly.

    A statistic can be accurate and still be presented in a way that creates a misleading impression. The public needs to know where the data came from, how the sample was selected, what age groups were included, how the relationships were classified and whether the figures distinguish consensual relationships from coercion, exploitation or abuse.

    There is also a difference between a 17-year-old and a 21-year-old, or an 18-year-old and a 20-year-old, and a much younger child involved with a substantially older adult. Those circumstances should not be lumped together as though they are identical. A close age gap between older teenagers and young adults does not, by itself, establish exploitation. Equally, it must never be used to dismiss abuse or disregard the law.

    The Antigua Observer report of June 18, 2026, attributed to Dr Frederick Nunes, described the 80 per cent figure as applying to Antigua and Barbuda and stated that 55 per cent of those pregnancies involved men aged 20 to 24. ASPIRE’s reply presents the 80 per cent figure as a Caribbean-wide statistic. That difference in how the figure is described needs clarification. What is the original study? What countries and years does it cover? And where is the breakdown showing the actual ages of both parties and the circumstances involved?

    If the data establish coercion or exploitation, then say so and show us the evidence. But if the data simply classify every pregnancy involving a teenage girl and a man aged 20 or older in one category, that does not tell the whole story. We should not use a headline statistic to imply that every such man is predatory or that every relationship involved coercion.

    I am not arguing that teenage pregnancy is harmless, or that older adults should escape scrutiny. I am arguing that public policy must be built on properly understood evidence. Statistics should illuminate the issue, not be used to manufacture a conclusion.

    Responsibility is not gender bias

    ASPIRE says that pregnancy does not happen by women alone. Of course it does not. But that observation does not invalidate the discussion of women’s agency, choices, boundaries and personal responsibility.

    Recognising that women have the capacity to make decisions about their intimate lives is not an attack on women. Encouraging young women to exercise discernment, establish standards, understand consequences and protect their own interests is not discrimination. It is a recognition of their agency.

    There are circumstances involving coercion, abuse, violence and unequal power that demand protection and intervention. Those cases must be taken seriously. But we should not allow the existence of those cases to erase every discussion about voluntary choices, sexual conduct and personal accountability.

    We can acknowledge vulnerability without treating every woman as incapable of making decisions. We can encourage self-respect and responsible choices without suggesting that women are responsible for the misconduct of others.

    Your argument should be mature enough to hold both ideas at once.

    Abortion: prevention deserves more than a passing mention

    I have never suggested that every pregnancy occurs under the same circumstances or that every abortion decision can be reduced to one explanation. There are medical emergencies, pregnancies arising from sexual violence, and exceptionally difficult personal circumstances. These realities deserve compassion and serious consideration.

    But there are also unintended pregnancies that arise from voluntary sexual activity, poor judgement, inadequate preparation or decisions made without sufficient thought for the consequences. We cannot have an honest conversation about reducing unintended pregnancies if prevention, restraint, informed decision-making and personal responsibility are treated as secondary issues.

    ASPIRE argues that decriminalisation is the path to fewer abortions. Yet its own response does not establish that changing the law, by itself, will address the social behaviours and circumstances that lead to unintended pregnancies.

    The international comparisons it cites also need careful interpretation. A relationship between abortion laws and abortion rates does not, on its own, prove that one caused the other. We must consider access to contraception, healthcare, education, reporting practices, socioeconomic conditions and the quality of the underlying data. Countries cannot simply be grouped into two categories and treated as though their circumstances are identical.

    If ASPIRE believes decriminalisation is the most effective policy for Antigua and Barbuda, it should explain how that conclusion follows from the evidence and how the proposed approach will reduce unintended pregnancies, protect women and address the circumstances that lead to abortion in the first place.

    A serious prevention strategy should not be an afterthought.

    What are we normalising?

    There is a wider social question here that I do not think we should ignore.

    A recent viral exchange on The Real Housewives of London brought the phrase “low-budget vagina” into public conversation. The confrontation between Karen Loderick-Peace and Amanda Cronin centred on wealth, property, status and allegations about relationships with influential men. I am not endorsing the insult or the personal allegations. The exchange is relevant only because it exposed, in crude and exaggerated fashion, how easily discussions about sex and relationships can become transactional: what someone has, what someone can offer, and what another person can gain.

    It raises a question worth considering: are we becoming comfortable with a social outlook in which sexuality is increasingly treated as a commodity and intimate relationships as transactions measured by financial or material benefit?

    People are free to make choices about their lives. But freedom to choose does not mean that every choice is beyond public discussion, nor does it mean that every social arrangement is worth promoting through public policy.

    If ASPIRE supports the regulation of prostitution, it must be prepared to explain the social consequences it has considered. What does it believe this industry would mean for our communities, our young people and the values we seek to encourage? What protections would be real and enforceable, rather than simply promised?

    This is not about determining anyone’s worth. It is about determining what we, as a society, are prepared to normalise and regulate.

    That’s a conversation we still need to have.

    I note ASPIRE’s reference to its work on Health and Family Life Education in Grenada and its outreach to religious leaders. Education is important, and I would welcome measurable evidence of the programme’s reach and impact. But education must be about more than access to information. It must also encourage sound judgement, responsibility, respect, healthy boundaries and an understanding of consequences.

    Ultimately, I am not asking ASPIRE to abandon its right to advocate. I am asking it to be more precise about what it is advocating and to answer the questions that its response has not addressed.

    What is ASPIRE’s actual policy position on prostitution in Antigua and Barbuda? What form of regulation does it support? What evidence shows that the model will protect vulnerable people rather than expand a commercial sex market? And what place do prevention, restraint, personal responsibility and social values have in its vision for our country?

    Those are reasonable questions. They are not gender bias, nor are they an attempt to silence anyone.

    Antigua and Barbuda deserves a debate that goes beyond slogans, selective statistics and accusations of prejudice. We can protect people from abuse, recognise difficult realities, and still insist on personal responsibility and thoughtful public policy.

    ASPIRE has responded to my letter. I acknowledge that. But the central question remains: what exactly are you proposing for prostitution in Antigua and Barbuda, and why should the people of this country believe it is the right direction for us?

    That is the question I would still like answered.

    Respectfully,

    Brent Simon

    This article was originally published by Antigua News Room. Read the original article here: LETTER: Aspire, Thank You For Responding. But The Central Question Remains Unanswered..

    Latest articles

    COP31 climate talks in deadlock as countries clash over fossil fuels and funding

    Negotiations at the United Nations COP31 climate summit in Turkey have reached a deadlock,...

    Antigua and Barbuda to review Labour Code in new parliamentary year

    Sir Steadroy Cutie BejaminAntigua and Barbuda’s Labour Code is due for a comprehensive review...

    Antigua and Barbuda plans two new teams to expand HAPI home repairs

    The Home Advancement Programme for the Indigent (HAPI) is preparing to expand its home...

    Former governor general praises Antigua and Barbuda’s CHOGM hosting

    Former Governor General Sir James Carlisle and Lady Carlisle have congratulated the government on...

    More like this

    COP31 climate talks in deadlock as countries clash over fossil fuels and funding

    Negotiations at the United Nations COP31 climate summit in Turkey have reached a deadlock,...

    Antigua and Barbuda to review Labour Code in new parliamentary year

    Sir Steadroy Cutie BejaminAntigua and Barbuda’s Labour Code is due for a comprehensive review...

    Antigua and Barbuda plans two new teams to expand HAPI home repairs

    The Home Advancement Programme for the Indigent (HAPI) is preparing to expand its home...